NYMF Roundup #1

By: David Finkle

Back to Reviews

Source: Theatre Mania.com

Reference: Joe Starts Again

 

Martin Croft in <i>Joe Starts Again</i>A musical about throwing oneself into the dating market after a partner has died can have universal appeal; witness the classic Hello, Dolly!, in which Dolly Gallagher Levi asks late hubby Ephraim for permission to move on. But Joe Starts Again, in which the eponymous fellow asks his deceased lover to wish him luck, covers the same territory in what could be termed a niche-musical manner.

Joe Thompson (Martin Croft, who wrote the lyrics to Dean Lotherington's melodies) is a 49-year-old gay man who's using a dating service to put himself out there. The hour-long piece that he commands, which ends just before his first date with an appropriate man, is so precise in its concerns and so emotionally honest that its immediate connection will surely be to one of musical theater's most supportive core audiences: homosexual men of a certain age. This is not to say that anyone uncertain about trying love the second time around won't respond, and -- man or woman -- get a kick out of the show's central comedy number, "I Shave My Balls."

Undoubtedly, actor-lyricist Croft has weathered Joe's experiences. That would explain the indisputably authentic feel to Joe's trying to get a prospective video right, to his recovering from an inadvertent date with a woman, to his stumbling through initial phone calls, and so on. The tall, bald and attractive Croft is writing about what he knows -- to some extent, at least. Composer Lotherington, while not supplying tunes that stick to the memory for the nearly sung-through show, does keep things melodic.

The dating service begins to seem a highly questionable enterprise when Joe is told by the service's unseen Sebastian to gay-up his video address. Do minions in this line of work truly suggest that clients mention Judy Garland and Barbra Streisand? Maybe so, but such clichés help to perpetuate harmful myths. It's commendable that Croft has Joe recoil from the suggestion -- though, eventually, he gives in. His affronted take is one of many epiphanies that Croft and Lotherington have packed into their adaption of Dating Joe, a play that Croft wrote with Mark Fletcher. Those worried about the future of the blockbuster musical can be heartened that the chamber musical alternative has candidates like Joe Starts Again.


[Australian Musicals.com NB] -
"Dating Joe" - the play that "Joe Starts Again" is based on was written by Mark Fletcher only, and not co-written by Martin Croft as the reviewer suggests.